IMPORTANT NOTE: You do NOT have to register to read, post, listen or contribute. If you simply wish to remain fully anonymous, you can still contribute.
Topic History of: Have I Got News... Max. showing the last 5 posts - (Last post first)
Author
Message
Prunella Minge
Yes, I quite agree. I still get it, but I don't why. Just habit I suppose!
JK2006
Agreed Pru - hasn't Private Eye gone off too?
Prunella Minge
I don't think the format is tired - you might as well say the sitcom format is tired because certain current sitcoms aren't good. Formats are formats - they rely on how you use them. It's down to the writers and performers. This period ought to be perfect for a satirical news show - it's not as if there's nothing to satirise! I think the HIGNFY writers have become very weak, Hislop spends far too much time addressing the audience, and Merton - the biggest problem, in my view - has become stunningly lazy. That blank gaze he does is so tiresome, and his 'ad-libs' are often just soundbites from old shows like Not Only But Also. The show needs younger writers and it needs to upset people again.
Marcus
I pretty much gave up on it a few years ago. It's become a part of the establishment it used to deride. Satire has a future, but this particular format has run its course.