IMPORTANT NOTE: You do NOT have to register to read, post, listen or contribute. If you simply wish to remain fully anonymous, you can still contribute.
Topic History of: Has anybody got any opinions on the current HMV situation? Max. showing the last 5 posts - (Last post first)
Author
Message
DJones
JK2006 wrote: Well you see my take is... you have to give a reason for people wanting to go out to a shop. So you create many; a far better quality download (equalised to your particular hearing and equipment specifications); burned for safety onto a CD/R; personal contact with others sharing your enthusiasm; private gigs; chance to be on TV; opportunity to record yourself; atmosphere - benefits you cannot get online.
But who pays attention to a Vile Pervert?
Obviously HMV: This is excatly the describtion of the "social media cafes" they try to install in their shops. 15 years too late, I'm afraid.
Even the people who want a physcial product look at the price. And buy online.
a far better quality download (equalised to your particular hearing and equipment specifications) - almost nobody cares about sound quality anymore. Who has the audio equipment or the hearing ability to distinguish between good & bad sound quality? And the (compressed) masters sound terrible anyway.
personal contact - Facebook.
chance to be on TV - YouTube
opportunity to record yourself - every PC & Mac & (some) mobile devices.
Burned CDs that look exactly like "real" CDs: What's the point? This is only interesting for the dealers (less costs etc.)
After BMG merged with Sony Music the new CEO of SONY BMG Germany - MAARTEN STEINKAMP - had an incredible great idea to stamp out piracy once and for all: Real (factory produced) CDs, but without colorful labels and without booklets. This was exactly the wrong strategy. What was needed than (but wouldn't make much difference now) was a high quality product at reasonable (lower) prices.
Metal Mickey
dixie wrote: I actually went to Tesco and burned a CD last week. I've shown it to friends and colleagues, and not one person could tell it had been manufactured in a Tesco store and not a factory.
Fair play - I haven't seen one of these new versions yet, I just had bad memories from V1.0 some years ago. If that's the case (and I'm impressed to hear it is), then there could be some life in it, as long as the content selection is there...
dixie
Metal Mickey wrote: This burn-your-own CD notion is a red herring - downloaders (legal or otherwise) don't need it at all, and those that want a physical product want an actual manufactured product, not a glorified CD-R with a photocopied sleeve, we can do that ourselves at home!! I'm very sad to say it, but last week's lowest-ever album sales is the real beginning of the end for physical music product...
I actually went to Tesco and burned a CD last week. I've shown it to friends and colleagues, and not one person could tell it had been manufactured in a Tesco store and not a factory. The CD itself was printed with the same label as the facyory copies. Same colour, logos content etc. The booklet was 8 pages printed in full colour and stapled - exactly as the factory made version. The back inlay was also printed 2 sides in colour. The only thing was a different barcode. I certainly couldn't achieve this at home - especially printing the label on the disc itself.
On the point of last week's low sales. I think it was a "freak week". Yes, sales are dropping, but I doubt we'll see another less than 10k No.1 album again this year.
JK2006
Well you see my take is... you have to give a reason for people wanting to go out to a shop. So you create many; a far better quality download (equalised to your particular hearing and equipment specifications); burned for safety onto a CD/R; personal contact with others sharing your enthusiasm; private gigs; chance to be on TV; opportunity to record yourself; atmosphere - benefits you cannot get online.
But who pays attention to a Vile Pervert?
Metal Mickey
This burn-your-own CD notion is a red herring - downloaders (legal or otherwise) don't need it at all, and those that want a physical product want an actual manufactured product, not a glorified CD-R with a photocopied sleeve, we can do that ourselves at home!! I'm very sad to say it, but last week's lowest-ever album sales is the real beginning of the end for physical music product...