Home  Forums |
|
|
|
|
Topic History of: Catfishing - manslaughter case
Max. showing the last 5 posts - (Last post first)
|
Green Man |
Wasn't an analogy Wyot, just saying there are other ways. |
|
Wyot |
Green Man wrote:
[quote]Wyot wrote:
Green Man wrote:
Well yes and no...There is a very easy and immediate death available via a loaded gun in the spur of the moment. A less accessible and immediate means of suicide may have led to hesitation...
The same can be said of jumping out of a window or standing in front of a train or lorry.
Unless she was as proximate to a very high window (to ensure death) as the gun or stood as near to a speeding train this is simply not true. In other words your analogies are less accessible and immediate means of suicide and actually illustrate rather than refute my point.
The parents allowed an easy immediate means of suicide within the place the child should have been safest, her home.
Additionally, the gun served no necessary purpose, unlike a window or train.
False analogy GM. |
|
Green Man |
Wyot wrote:
Green Man wrote:
It's bad parenting Wyot, sadly if it was not the gun; the poor girl would have found something else to end her life.
Well yes and no...There is a very easy and immediate death available via a loaded gun in the spur of the moment. A less accessible and immediate means of suicide may have led to hesitation...
The same can be said of jumping out of a window or standing in front of a train or lorry. |
|
Wyot |
Green Man wrote:
It's bad parenting Wyot, sadly if it was not the gun; the poor girl would have found something else to end her life.
Well yes and no...There is a very easy and immediate death available via a loaded gun in the spur of the moment. A less accessible and immediate means of suicide may have led to hesitation... |
|
Green Man |
It's bad parenting Wyot, sadly if it was not the gun; the poor girl would have found something else to end her life. |
|
|
|
