JK2006 wrote:
I do think Craig is far and away the best Judge and always has been.
Very nice man, but he makes the most of his alotted role. Len was at least, if not more, astute than him. But Craig's role is to be hyper strict. 'Okay over to you - leave all the really specific technical stuff because that's Craig's job...' Not really fair on the others. A bit like on a reimagined Juke Box Jury - 'okay, you concentrate on the outfits, you on the personalities, you on the beat and, oh, you, you act like you're Hans Keller'. All the judges could be at least as exacting as Craig. They're just told to do other things. Production-wise, they don't want repetition in responses, but I feel for the other judges, they're left looking 'loose' compared to Craig.
Warning: Spoiler!Mike and Katya vs David and Nadiya in dance off. David and Nadiya out