This is a great post about the reviews of R.E.M albums by Rolling Stone:
www.huffingtonpost.com/bill-wyman/rock-c...-if-you_b_94959.html
"So Up was better than Automatic for the People ... and worthy of comparison not just to OK Computer but Sgt. Pepper.
It sure didn't sound that bad.
At that point, we realized what the problem was. R.E.M. had set the bar for itself, and reviewers, impossibly high. On its eleventh studio album, Up, the group had come up with a Sgt. Pepper-like masterpiece.
Since then, critics have had to deal with something unexpected. R.E.M. have consistently topped that stirring work, each successive release being so good as to make clear the flaws of the one before it.
At this point, the implication is clear: As far as Rolling Stone is concerned, R.E.M.'s best work is ahead of it."