This has to be one of the most stunning interviews I have ever heard on radio. The famous USA radio station called Coast to Coast interviewing a teacher about her pupil aged 6 who claims to come from the planet ( destroyed ) Reptillia and is part reptile.

www.divshare.com/download/5416244-01c

Looks as if ICKE could be totally right about all of this !!! and we all laughed in 1999 when he first wrote about this possibility.

BR, I'm not sure if you actually believe this or not...

I do not detect much irony in your post.

Nutters!

Well it is an interesting interview.

I am a skeptic about anything like this - especially from the USA !!

However, have you listened to the interview. It stands up to scrutiny and unless the person who was ringing the radio station was telling lies then it is quite an interesting story which needs investigation - sort of X FILES style.

If ( and I say IF ) the teacher is telling the truth then as the radio interviewer suggests the child should be assessed because this is very strange stuff.

If it is true what would be your view on the situation and what it would mean >? (hypothetically of course because it is 99% likely not to be true according to our human experience )

"...stands up to scrutiny"?

What have you done to verify this?

(ETA landing on water... a clear reference to the Picean-aliens the TRUE overlords!)

It stands up to scrutiny if you listen to the whole interview IF you believe the teacher. In other words it is her word against anyone else.

If you have listened to the interview all the way through you will know WHAT SHE SAYS which proved to her this was MORE than just an active imagination. It was proof.

So if she is telling the truth there is proof. If she is a liar then it is a load of crap.

You have not listened to the interview or you would know what I am talking about.

99% of people in the USA are mad and are liars or deluded in some way ( we know this from their films and handling of their economy and the way they went into Iraq looking for something that did not exist )

So on that basis I disbelieve this story. But within its own sphere if she is telling the truth then it could be true. That is what is so fascinating about it. A real mystery.

What I found interesting was that she clearly believed it - because she implies that the child needs psychiatric assistance and not that she thinks he's a reptile.

Which makes it more believable.

As to whether the child is fantasising - who knows? But the details of her house when she was 6 clearly rattled her.

If only he hadn't said the planet was called Reptillia

But supposing it was, Al?

Or supposing the real name could not be understood by a more primitive species?

BR wrote:
It stands up to scrutiny if you listen to the whole interview IF you believe the teacher.In other words it is her word against anyone else.

Everything under the sun stands up to scrutiny using that criterion.

All the teacher does is to recount what the boy says. Whether she believes him is not relevant.

I suppose it could be true, but off the top of my head I can't think of anything less likely to be true.

All the same it was an entertaining interview, so thanks for sharing it.

I cannot believe that some seem to be giving the kid's story any credence...

If anyone is really interested in THE TRUTH (especially the God botherers amongst you), then look no further...

video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-594683847743189197

2 hours long !! Pete I dont have that much time on my hands - can you sum it up in a paragraph for us please

Yes - it was the bedroom bit that was deeply disturbing.

I thought that about Reptillia - why call a planet after a race - but as someone says - it is only a translation in any case if what he says is true.

We all agree that DNA is transmitted from our parents to us - and perhaps this child has had some sort of DNA revelation from thousands of years ago - but that still does not explain the bedroom.

I am 99% sure that this is a lie - but 1% of me is very unsure because this teacher is a) A convincing liar and b) it does not sound made up the information she chose to give out.

She was also asking for advice rather than trying to get "fame" or whatever believing that this radio station could put her in touch with someone who might be able to explain what was happening to this child.

Certainly something that I wish TV would do a documentary about.

BR wrote:
It stands up to scrutiny if you listen to the whole interview IF you believe the teacher. In other words it is her word against anyone else.

If you have listened to the interview all the way through you will know WHAT SHE SAYS which proved to her this was MORE than just an active imagination. It was proof.

So if she is telling the truth there is proof. If she is a liar then it is a load of crap.

You have not listened to the interview or you would know what I am talking about.

99% of people in the USA are mad and are liars or deluded in some way ( we know this from their films and handling of their economy and the way they went into Iraq looking for something that did not exist )

So on that basis I disbelieve this story. But within its own sphere if she is telling the truth then it could be true. That is what is so fascinating about it. A real mystery.
I have listened to the interview. My question was what have you done to verify it it.

An answer of "I listened to what was said" isn't exactly hardcore scepticism is it?

Anecdote is not proof.

Yes, it's quite a long film but definitely worth watching when you have the time.

It's summed up quite well here:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeitgeist,_the_Movie

What's interesting, is the lack of any real 'debunking' of this film.

The points made in first section, about organised religion, stand up to scrutiny.

Also, part III talks about how the US Federal Reserve Bank manufactured Big Depression. It's very relevant to what's happening today.

Thanks Pete will read all of that later.