IMPORTANT NOTE: You do NOT have to register to read, post, listen or contribute. If you simply wish to remain fully anonymous, you can still contribute.
|
Home Forums |
The Queen: What's The Point?
TOPIC: The Queen: What's The Point?
|
|
Re:The Queen: What's The Point? 13 Years, 12 Months ago
|
|
As Walter Bagehot noted all those years ago, it's always an incredible suspension of belief: yesterday you had a monarch who still has much of the formal power that Charles I had, but she doesn't use them in practice, meeting the new holder of the post of First Lord of the Treasury, who also calls himself the holder of a post that doesn't really formally exist, Prime Minister, and the new resident of a house he has no obligation to use (Harold and Mary used to go in the front, out the back and off to their own house). And in subsequent meetings between PM and monarch, he will 'advise' her to use her own powers to ratify what he has already decided to do. And yet in some weird way it works, or appears to work, or something somewhere inbetween. What a muddled constitution we have. No wonder we have far fewer constitutional lawyers than they do in the US - it's the fast track to a nervous breakdown.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
Re:The Queen: What's The Point? 13 Years, 12 Months ago
|
|
Although Fat Controller is correct in an intellectual sense I believe without the Royal family Britain would fall apart. They are like a glue that holds it all together.
An example to compare is the Thai royal family...adored by the people and the king as the longest reinging monarch in the world is now 80 with prostrate cancer.
The Thai people adore his daughter ( who bats for the other team)..and to see her motocade you can see why. A dozen outriders in glorious uniforms..about ten brown Toyotas carrying staff (nothing as crass as a Roller)and in the middle driving a battered ancient Volkswagen is the Princess.
But the succession in theory must go to the Prince..a hugely unpopular playboy. When the king dies if he takes over I predict Thailand will collapse into a nightmare.
You should look forward to King William...he will be the most popular royal ever !
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
Re:The Queen: What's The Point? 13 Years, 12 Months ago
|
|
Liz and Phil, an informal portrait:
Oh, the Commonwealth! Isn't it all so lovely?
I hate the bloody Commonwealth and you bloody well KNOW it! I could be playing POLO in bloody SLOUGH by now!
There are times when I wish I'd never married you!
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
Last Edit: 2010/05/12 13:26 By Prunella Minge.
|
|
|
|
Re:The Queen: What's The Point? 13 Years, 12 Months ago
|
|
of course it's an illusion but it works doesn't it ?
and I think HRH The Queen is hugely popular.
I waited in a school line-up when I was 6 in summer when she came to our school but I fainted so I never saw her.
That's the effect she has on me. Although it could have been the heat and the excitement.
|
|
|
Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|