One of the best. Loved it.

Just as you thought things were getting better the awful Pond turns up again.

Terrible ending.

Now now PH, just 'cause neither you nor I are into ginger, don't lose the spirit of Christmas goodwill!

I like ginger wine ... if that helps ..?

You old drunk, you!

Thought it was wonderful myself, loved the Doctor's tear at the end. Also loved the way that WW2 was portrayed in the romantic way it was, people were constantly resourceful and Madge quite accepted a Spaceman crashing into ground near her and the TARDIS de-materialising at the end. A real piece of Christmas drama, if anything the light to the dark, depressing mood of Eastenders (Deadenders more like) later on in the evening. If anyone smiled in Eastenders, there would be a government inquiry!

I thought it mundane at best. Predictable 'life affirming' ending, silly plot involving trees becoming stars in the sky (yuk) and a completely wet mother who bore no relation to real hard as nails 1940s wartime women.

Better than last years though.

Delightful?
Pathetic.
Who is Dr Who for these days? Babies?

Hamlet wrote:

Better than last years though.

I thought last years was the better of the two, but it did have the benefit of the delightful Katherine Jenkins.